How to Create Success in Newly Promoted Managers

Default Author • February 3, 2021

Hey, don’t forget, new Managers need training. People leave managers, not companies.

One common complaint we hear from job seekers when we are deciphering their ideal working environments, is that they often feel unsupported by their managers.

 As we dig further, it becomes all too apparent that in many organisations, newly appointed managers are not receiving the support they need in order to be successful in their role. This creates a knock-on effect of employees not feeling supported and before you know it – you have a vicious cycle on your hands.

Thinking about promoting one of the team into a managerial position?

Getting to the nub of the issue, success starts right at the beginning of the promotion phase with several questions that need answering:

  • Are the right people being promoted?
  • What qualities should a good manager have?
  • What ongoing should the organisation offer?

Before going any further, consider the following to ensure you are fostering a collaborative environment for the entire team.

Q1: Does your employee actually want to be a manager?

This question may seem very obvious but for some reason, all too often, it is overlooked in the wider scheme of workforce planning. But the reality is … not everyone wants to be a manager. And that’s okay.

Success lies in promoting employees who truly want to lead and can handle all the responsibilities that come with their new job title.

Great managers believe that the goals of others are as important as their own and as such, make the time for others. They build meaningful relationships that can then serve to achieve results together, as a team. So, does this person enjoy helping others achieve their goals?

The impact of poor managers can be catastrophic. Decreased employee morale, increased staff turnover, increased absenteeism, reduced market share and a reduced bottom line – so finding someone who actually wants to manage and understands what it means to be a leader, is essential.

Q2: Is the manager a communicator or listener?

We all know that communication is the foundation of every successful relationship but the fact is; ‘the soft stuff is the hard stuff’ for most managers.

Managers need to communicate with all employees in a way that they understand as well as being open to hearing about ideas, suggestions or concerns that their team have to offer.

And here’s how simple it can be… in a study of 85,000 adult workers in the US in 2014, a high percentage admitted they would work harder if they simply received more praise for their efforts. That’s it!

Wrapped up in communication skills, a successful manager will have solid people skills which are the essence of leadership. Being able to relate to others and for others to be able to relate to you is critical in earning trust and building a foundation of respect.

Q3: Can they motivate the team?

As mentioned, many employees feel that they do not feel supported by their manager, so when selecting an employee for promotion, it is important to assess that this person can focus on the success of the entire team.

It means having a genuine understanding of what employees need to feel motivated and valued. It’s about the ability to connect with the team in a truthful, sincere and genuine way so that team members feel they are being listened to and understood. Insincerity is sniffed out so quickly in the work place – it’s not something that can be faked – it has to be real.

Employees want to know that their bosses see their efforts and truly value it. This connects to a feeling of job security, well-being, and opportunities for development. And it affirms that the whole team is seen as being trustworthy, dependable, creative and resourceful.

In short, by ensuring employees feel motivated, recognised and rewarded, the platform is set for a positive working environment, increased productivity and skyrocketing results.

Now what? Provide training!

Now that you have assessed this is the right candidate for promotion, it is essential to develop and implement ongoing support for the new manager. Contrary to popular opinion, learning to be a good manager takes time because good talent management skills are not intuitive to most. Training is about:

  • Giving effective feedback
  • Coaching employees
  • Tracking employee performance
  • Setting clear goals
  • Developing employees
  • Recognising and rewarding good performance
  • Dealing with performance issues

There really is no excuse not to provide training. There are loads of excellent books, podcasts, blogs, webinars, training courses, mentors and coaches, articles, seminars and short courses available to help your managers develop or hone a basic talent management suite of skills.

Your investment in developing strong employee performance and talent management skills in your managers will pay off in terms of high employee performance, employee engagement, satisfaction, retention, and ultimately, improved organisational results.

Feedback is vital

Receiving performance feedback from others is one of the best ways for a manager to learn. Identify people who can help your managers identify their strengths and areas that need development, without judgment or condemnation.

The best way for an organisation to support their management is to provide ongoing support and training, just as you expect managers will do for their teams.

Open lines of communications between managers, their supervisors or the business owners are needed as is a willingness to foster a whole company environment that is supportive of the needs of its employees. This creates an ideal knock-on effect and before you know you have a virtuous circle in place.

For more information on promoting new managers in your organisation, or information on recruiting management for your company, contact us today.

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Mark Green April 9, 2025
With 68% of Australian workers worried about potential redundancies, job security is now a top priority—especially in tech sectors across NSW and WA. In this blog, people2people’s Mark Green explores how employee preferences have shifted from salary-driven goals to long-term stability. As uncertainty grows, businesses must adapt by fostering transparent communication and building trust. We also share essential tips for leaders navigating redundancy conversations with empathy and strategy. Want to know how to retain top talent and protect your employer brand during uncertain times? Discover how to support your workforce and strengthen loyalty in today’s cautious job market.
By Mark Green April 7, 2025
As return-to-office mandates rise across Australia, many leaders face the challenge of balancing productivity with employee preferences. In this blog, Mark Green from people2people and Maja Paleka from MPC unpack the drivers behind these mandates, their impact on engagement and retention, and why forcing full-time office returns may backfire. With hybrid work models proving effective for many, forward-thinking businesses are seizing this moment to attract top talent and build trust-based cultures. We also share practical tips for leaders navigating this shift in 2025. Wondering how to future-proof your workplace without losing your best people? Read on to find out more.
By Suhini Wijayasinghe March 31, 2025
Millennials are now leading teams made up of both older and younger generations—but how do they bridge the gap between Baby Boomer values and Gen Z expectations? In this blog, we explore leadership in a multigenerational workforce with insights from Ramp Fitness co-founder Matthew Papalo. From building scalable systems to fostering community and wellbeing, discover how modern leaders are adapting to new workplace demands. If you're a millennial manager (or aspire to be one), this is your guide to leading with resilience, empathy, and innovation. Want to know the key to staying ahead of the curve in 2025 and beyond?
By Aiden Boast March 26, 2025
Feeling stuck in your job? You’re not alone—60% of workers are staying in roles longer than they’d like due to financial concerns and fear of instability. Yet, 66% believe a career change could make them happier. In this blog, people2people’s Aiden Boast unpacks recent data revealing why so many professionals are hesitant to move on, despite growing demand for skills-based hiring and flexible work options. Learn practical tips for overcoming career stagnation, leveraging your transferable skills, and taking the first steps toward a more fulfilling role. Could now be the perfect time to rethink your career path? Read more to find out.
By Janet Gebre March 24, 2025
Artificial intelligence (AI) has rapidly moved from being a futuristic concept to a practical tool already reshaping industries—including human resources. In fact, recent surveys show that 68% of HR leaders have already integrated AI into their hiring processes. From automating repetitive tasks to enhancing candidate experiences, AI is unlocking new efficiencies across the entire recruitment lifecycle. As AI becomes more mainstream, HR teams are leveraging tools like chatbots, generative AI platforms, and applicant tracking systems with built-in intelligence to save time and make smarter decisions. Whether it’s auto-sorting CVs, drafting communications, or delivering data-backed insights, AI is now a critical element in HR’s toolkit. However, with these benefits come valid concerns. Questions around bias, ethics, data quality, and the fear of losing the “human touch” still hold some organisations back from adopting AI. For businesses looking to remain competitive in today’s fast-moving job market, understanding how AI works—and how to use it responsibly—is essential. With AI quickly becoming a core part of HR strategy, the challenge for many professionals isn’t whether to adopt it, but how to do so effectively while maintaining fairness and empathy in the hiring process. “Sixty-eight percent of HR leaders have integrated AI into their hiring,” In a recent live stream, Aiden Boast, Temporary Specialist Recruitment Team Leader at people2people, sat down with Nicole Ashe, HR expert and author of The People Perspective, to explore how AI is shaping recruitment and the workplace. Aiden kicked things off by highlighting the growing adoption of AI in hiring. “Sixty-eight percent of HR leaders have integrated AI into their hiring,” he noted. “As AI continues to reshape the hiring process for many, businesses that embrace it are gaining a competitive edge.” Nicole explained that AI is not a singular tool but a suite of technologies working together to improve HR outcomes. “AI is about augmenting—it’s about lifting your expertise in HR or talent acquisition and levelling it up,” she said. “It can predict outcomes, automate repetitive tasks, and provide insights HR professionals need to make better decisions.” She emphasised how everyday tools like Copilot and ChatGPT are already making life easier for HR teams. “Once you train AI in your brand or voice of your organisation, it won’t sound artificial… it actually lifts your game,” she added. One surprising use case Nicole shared involved public transport: “AI is already used by Transport NSW to adjust traffic lights, helping Sydney buses run on time.” Closer to HR, she noted, “Platforms like LinkedIn Learning are using AI to suggest training based on people’s skills and career goals.” Aiden then raised a key concern: resistance from HR leaders. Nicole was quick to respond. “The biggest concern is bias,” she said. “AI is only as good as the data it learns from. If your past hiring practices have bias, that will carry through.” She also acknowledged a common fear: that AI might replace human roles. “It’s not about replacing recruiters—it’s about enabling them to focus more on relationships and less on admin,” she explained. “AI lets recruiters get back to understanding candidates, building connections, and making more informed decisions.” The conversation also touched on misconceptions. Nicole noted, “People think AI makes final hiring decisions, but it’s only one part of the process.” The real opportunity lies in combining human judgment with AI-generated insights to deliver faster, fairer, and more effective hiring. As AI becomes more embedded in day-to-day workflows, HR leaders will need to sharpen their skills. “AI literacy is becoming essential,” Nicole said. “It doesn’t mean you need to be an engineer, but you must understand what AI can and can’t do.” She encouraged organisations to take a phased approach to AI adoption. “Start small—maybe with a chatbot or automating email responses—then build from there,” she suggested. “HR’s role is also to help shape governance and ethical frameworks around how AI is used.” Aiden closed the conversation with appreciation for Nicole’s insights. “It’s fascinating how AI is already integrated in so many ways. Thanks for helping us understand the potential—and the pitfalls.” Key Strategies for HR Leaders Embracing AI As more companies integrate AI into their HR systems, leaders should consider the following strategies to successfully navigate the transition: 1. Prioritise AI literacy. HR teams must understand how AI works, what it can do, and where its limits are. This means upskilling staff to interpret AI-driven insights and manage its outputs responsibly. 2. Start small and scale. Begin with manageable projects like automating scheduling or implementing a recruitment chatbot. As confidence and understanding grow, expand into more complex areas like predictive analytics and performance tracking. 3. Always involve human oversight. AI is a tool—not a replacement. HR professionals should validate AI outputs, especially in candidate selection, to ensure fairness and ethical decision-making. 4. Monitor for bias. Regularly audit AI tools to ensure they’re not perpetuating bias from past hiring decisions. This includes reviewing data sources, outputs, and how algorithms rank candidates. 5. Build clear governance policies. Develop and enforce frameworks around AI use, including transparency, data privacy, and accountability. Define who is responsible for monitoring outcomes and adjusting systems when needed. 6. Use AI to free up time for human connection. Let AI handle time-consuming tasks so HR professionals can focus on strategic initiatives, candidate engagement, and employee experience—the parts of HR that truly require a human touch. 7. Treat AI as a collaborative partner. Think of AI as a personal assistant. When trained correctly, it enhances productivity, creativity, and accuracy, but the final decisions should still rest with people. As AI continues to revolutionise HR practices, those who embrace it thoughtfully and ethically will be better positioned to attract talent, improve candidate experiences, and drive long-term success.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us