Interview Tips for Managers new to the Hiring Process

Anthony Demarco • September 23, 2020

“You never get a second chance to make a first impression” – Will Rogers

28…29…30...BOOM a job seeker has made an impression on you and your business within the first 30 seconds of meeting with you. It is no longer just about the job seeker selling themselves to you, but also, are you selling the role and business to the job seeker? For a manager that is new to the hiring process, there can be a lot of pressure when interviewing a potential employee. Being able to effectively interview is crucial to attracting the top talent to your business. Below are my top tips to help you through this process.

1. Preparation

Always spend time preparing for each interview, it will make you feel a lot more confident when meeting the candidate. I recommend putting together agenda points for the interview which you can share with the candidate to add more structure. Always thoroughly read through the candidate’s resume prior to meeting them so you can reference your conversation back to their CV and previous experience.

2. Build a rapport

So many times when I take interview feedback from candidates who have interviewed with hiring managers, they will say “I got a really good feeling from the person who interviewed me, we had a great chat and got on really well”. It makes a massive difference if you get to know the candidate on a personal level and not just focusing on if they can do the job. This will also allow you to assess what type of personality they have and if they will fit with existing staff members.

3. Sell the benefits

It is normal for a candidate to be considering two or three different options during their job search (ideally). No longer is salary the most important thing for job seekers, it is the benefits that businesses offer such as flexible working, social and team events, health and wellbeing projects etc. It is important to share these with candidates in the interview, as well as highlighting any achievements the business has enjoyed.

4. Call to action

It is important to leave the candidate feeling comfortable at the end of an interview, I would always recommend setting clear expectations of when they will be hearing back from you and what the next steps are.

If you are new to the hiring process and would like further advice, please don’t hesitate to reach me on 02 8270 9715 or [email protected]

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia   I   United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.



Share insights

Recent articles

By Leanne Lazarus April 23, 2025
A strong safety culture is critical to reducing risk and promoting wellbeing in Australian workplaces. With 40% of workers exposed to moderate to high psychosocial risks, organisations must move beyond basic compliance to foster environments where employees feel genuinely safe and supported. In this blog, people2people’s Leanne Lazarus speaks with legal and safety experts Jonathan Mamaril and Nettie Herselman on how businesses can embed safety-first thinking into their culture. Discover practical tips for leadership, internal compliance, and strategic planning to build a resilient, engaged workforce. Is your organisation doing enough to protect both the physical and psychological safety of its people?
By Mark Green April 9, 2025
With 68% of Australian workers worried about potential redundancies, job security is now a top priority—especially in tech sectors across NSW and WA. In this blog, people2people’s Mark Green explores how employee preferences have shifted from salary-driven goals to long-term stability. As uncertainty grows, businesses must adapt by fostering transparent communication and building trust. We also share essential tips for leaders navigating redundancy conversations with empathy and strategy. Want to know how to retain top talent and protect your employer brand during uncertain times? Discover how to support your workforce and strengthen loyalty in today’s cautious job market.
By Mark Green April 7, 2025
As return-to-office mandates rise across Australia, many leaders face the challenge of balancing productivity with employee preferences. In this blog, Mark Green from people2people and Maja Paleka from MPC unpack the drivers behind these mandates, their impact on engagement and retention, and why forcing full-time office returns may backfire. With hybrid work models proving effective for many, forward-thinking businesses are seizing this moment to attract top talent and build trust-based cultures. We also share practical tips for leaders navigating this shift in 2025. Wondering how to future-proof your workplace without losing your best people? Read on to find out more.
By Suhini Wijayasinghe March 31, 2025
Millennials are now leading teams made up of both older and younger generations—but how do they bridge the gap between Baby Boomer values and Gen Z expectations? In this blog, we explore leadership in a multigenerational workforce with insights from Ramp Fitness co-founder Matthew Papalo. From building scalable systems to fostering community and wellbeing, discover how modern leaders are adapting to new workplace demands. If you're a millennial manager (or aspire to be one), this is your guide to leading with resilience, empathy, and innovation. Want to know the key to staying ahead of the curve in 2025 and beyond?
By Aiden Boast March 26, 2025
Feeling stuck in your job? You’re not alone—60% of workers are staying in roles longer than they’d like due to financial concerns and fear of instability. Yet, 66% believe a career change could make them happier. In this blog, people2people’s Aiden Boast unpacks recent data revealing why so many professionals are hesitant to move on, despite growing demand for skills-based hiring and flexible work options. Learn practical tips for overcoming career stagnation, leveraging your transferable skills, and taking the first steps toward a more fulfilling role. Could now be the perfect time to rethink your career path? Read more to find out.

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us